Skip to main content

Seeking information from our Parliamentary candidates

At the start of Refugee week ,it seemed appropriate to write to the Candidates for the forthcoming Parliamentary  election to seek their views.

Thus with agreement from trustees, this email was sent on 15th June 2024 to the candidates for the Abolish the Welsh Assembly Party, The Conservative and Unionist party, The Green Party, The Labour Party, The Liberal Democrats, the  Monster Raving Loony party and Plaid Cymru.
Dear Candidate,
I trust that you are well and will be prepared to share your views with our group..
I am the Secretary of HBTSR and  represent over 500 people who are active members of our group. Our Trustees have asked me to write.                             
A fair, humane asylum system is one of the main issues that will determine our vote.
We’d be very grateful for your thoughts on the following questions
What steps will you take to defend the right to seek asylum in the UK and build a fair and compassionate asylum system?
Will you support giving the right to work for people seeking asylum?
What will you do to ensure people seeking asylum are able to live in safe, dignified accommodation in our communities?
How do you feel about the system of Detention without time limits?
I will ensure that your answers are shared with members via our website.
 Best wishes,
As the replies return, I will post them here…
=============================================
19/06/2024
from Matthew Dorrance
Dear Ailsa,
Thank you for this email which asks important question of those seeking to represent us.
I have answered below for the information of your members:
Q: What steps will you take to defend the right to seek asylum in the UK and build a fair and compassionate asylum system?
I believe in a fairer and kinder asylum system where people seeking asylum are supported, provided with care and not demonised or blamed for economic and social injustice in the UK.
I was pleased to attend the first ever meeting of Hay, Talgarth and Brecon Sanctuary for Refugees, I have enjoyed seeing the movement grow and I have continued to support the work the group does.
Through my work as Deputy Leader of the County Council and as an active citizen I have been fortunate to spend time with people seeking refuge. I am proud of the Welsh Labour approach in working to make Wales a Nation of Sanctuary, establishing welcome centres and responding to the call for action in the wake of humanitarian crises. I also supported Powys County Council’s agreement to be a Council of Sanctuary.
I will continue to advocate for human rights – which the right to seek asylum is and which must be defended.
Q: Will you support giving the right to work for people seeking asylum?
Yes. People seeking asylum bring with them a wealth of talent and experience. Enabling people seeking asylum to work can only benefit our communities and our economy. We can see the evidence on this from the Ukrainian support scheme.  It will also give people human dignity.
Q: What will you do to ensure people seeking asylum are able to live in safe, dignified accommodation in our communities?
Housing is a significant pressure locally.  I know, from serving as Council Cabinet Member for Housing, that we do not have enough homes for social rent in Powys and we are dealing with more complex housing needs. That’s why I put in place a plan to build new council homes and to buy former council homes back – enabling us to address increasing homelessness in the County.
I believe that everyone should have a safe and secure home. I worked with partners in the Council and NHS to press the Home Office into scrapping plans to use a disused hotel in Powys to house asylum seekers. We worked together to do this on the grounds that the property is unfit for habitation. I also oppose the use of barge and former military camps for accommodation as they clearly do not meet acceptable standards.
Q: How do you feel about the system of Detention without time limits?
There must be a kinder and fairer way to help people seeking asylum.  The current system fails everyone – the asylum seeker, the country and the economy.
Labour will stop the chaos and go after the criminal gangs who trade in driving this crisis. We will create a new Border Security Command, with hundreds of new investigators, intelligence officers, and cross-border police officers.
This will be funded by ending the wasteful Migration and Economic Development partnership with Rwanda.
This new Command will work internationally and be supported by new counter-terrorism style powers, to pursue, disrupt, and arrest those responsible for the vile trade. We will seek a new security agreement with the EU to ensure access to real-time intelligence and enable our policing teams to lead joint investigations with their European counterparts. Labour will turn the page and restore order to the asylum system so that it operates swiftly, firmly, and fairly; and the rules are properly enforced. We will hire additional caseworkers to clear the Conservatives’ backlog and end asylum hotels, saving the taxpayer billions of pounds. And we will also act upstream, working with international partners to address the humanitarian crises which lead people to flee their homes, and to strengthen support for refugees in their home region.
I hope these answers are helpful.  if there is anything else that I can do please do not hesitate to contact me.
With best wishes,
Matthew
===============================================
26/06/2024
FROM David Chadwick
Dear Ailsa,
Please find my answers below.

What steps will you take to defend the right to seek asylum in the UK and build a fair and compassionate asylum system?

I will be fighting for a fair and effective immigration system that treats everyone with dignity and respect. The Liberal Democrats would scrap the Conservatives’ Illegal Migration Act and their Rwanda scheme, uphold the Refugee Convention, and provide safe and legal routes to sanctuary for refugees, helping to prevent dangerous Channel crossings.

We would tackle the asylum backlog by establishing a dedicated unit to improve the speed and quality of asylum decision-making, introducing a service standard of three months for all but the most complex asylum claims to be processed, and speeding up returns of those without a right to stay.

Will you support giving the right to work for people seeking asylum?
Yes. Over the past few years I have been privileged to meet many refugees, including last summer’s welcome event hosted by the Hay, Brecon and Talgarth Sanctuary for refugees. The people I met were talented people who wanted to work hard. It is shameful that we are not enabling them to work and contribute to our society, particularly when we have such labour shortages. We should lift the ban on asylum seekers working if they have been waiting for a decision for more than three months, enabling them to support themselves, integrate in our communities and contribute to the economy.

 

What will you do to ensure people seeking asylum are able to live in safe, dignified accommodation in our communities?
Due to the chronic shortage of social housing, many refugees have been housed in unsuitable and squalid hotels, and other forms of emergency accommodation. There have been worrying reports of children going missing. In 2012 The Liberal Democrats ended the previous Labour Government’s practice of detaining children for immigration purposes. Shamefully, our Conservative government has decided that their anti-refugee rhetoric is more important than safeguarding children from exploitation. The UK and Welsh governments must invest in safe accommodation for refugees, whether that be more social housing or in conjunction with third sector providers such as Barnardos.

 

How do you feel about the system of Detention without time limits?

The Liberal Democrats have a long history of blocking or campaigning against detention without charge. For instance, in 2005 Liberal Democrat MPs voted down Tony Blair’s proposal to allow police to hold suspects for 90 days without charge. Detention without charge should be an absolute last resort, capped at 28 days.  

Please do read the Liberal Democrats’ manifesto here for further information. 

Thank you!

David Chadwick 
============================================================
Here is a summary of manifesto pledges produced  on 26/06 by Detention Action

Immigration Detention

The Liberal Democrats say they will end the immigration detention of children and implement a 28-day time limit for the detention of adults. The Green Party proposes to end immigration detention for all migrants, unless they are “a danger to public safety”. Labour, the Conservatives, Plaid Cymru and the Scottish National Party (SNP) don’t discuss detention in their manifestos.

The UK-Rwanda Policy and Offshore Processing

In their manifesto, the Conservatives say they will follow through with this policy, ensuring that people seeking asylum are sent regularly and by force to Rwanda, starting in July. The Labour Party have said that they would drop this policy, as have the Liberal Democrats, Plaid Cymru and the SNP.

People Seeking Asylum

The Labour Party have said they will “restore order to the asylum system, ensuring it operates swiftly, firmly, and fairly with rules properly enforced.” This includes hiring more asylum caseworkers to clear the backlog of claims and negotiating “additional returns arrangements to increase the number of safe countries that failed asylum seekers can swiftly be sent back to”.

The Conservatives have promised to bring the Illegal Migration Act into force and stop migrants from challenging their removal. The Liberal Democrats say they would cancel the Illegal Migration Act, uphold the Refugee Convention, provide safe and legal routes for refugees and help prevent dangerous Channel crossings. The Green Party acknowledge the right to claim asylum and say they will campaign for an asylum system that treats applicants fairly, humanely, and without discrimination, with ‘‘a fast and fair process to assess asylum applications.’’

=========================